Saudi Political Intolerance

01.26.16
Pete Souza
World News /26 Jan 2016
01.26.16

Saudi Political Intolerance

Public beheadings, including that of a prominent Saudi Shiite cleric, prompted reactions not only inside Saudi Arabia but also in Iran, Iraq and most recently in Bahrain.

Saudi Arabia’s death wedding in January 2016 highlights the Kingdom’s intolerance towards any dissent against the royal family. The Saudi law of January 2014 doesn’t “merely criminalize dissent,” but defines it as “terrorism,” according to The Independent.

While claiming to fight against terrorism, Saudi Arabia is looking forward to settling political scores inside and outside its borders. The executions are not unprecedented in Saudi Arabia. Only in 2015, the average executions reached 12 persons every month. Western allies, Saudi Arabia and other Gulf States know that there are consequences. Historically, western powers have nearly always turned a blind eye to atrocities attributed to their Gulf allies because of economic calculations like oil and armaments. Thus, historical allies are unwilling or unable to affect real change.

Recent Escalations

On January 23rd in the Bahraini Island Sitra, close to the capital Manama, violent clashes broke out between police forces and demonstrators. These clashes were part the on- going three-week-protests condemning Saudi Arabia’s execution of Nimr Al-Nimr. Hundreds of Al-Nimr supporters marched in Al-Qatif in Saudi Arabia’s eastern province in protest of the execution. The protestors were chanting: “Down with the Al-Saud,” the name of the Saudi royal family.

Saudi Arabia’s ambassador in Iraq, Thamer Al-Sabhan, said to Al-Sumaria TV that: “Iraqi reactions to the execution of Al-Nimr has raised eyebrows in the Kingdom, especially that they did not condemn the attack on our embassy in Iran.”

Al-Sabhan revealed that the Saudi embassy in Baghdad had “received serious threats” following the executions.

Iran considers Al-Nimr to be “the champion of a marginalized Shiite minority” in the Arabian Peninsula. Al-Nimr was jailed and then sentenced to death because of his political role during the period of the Arab uprising between 2011 and 2013, when he campaigned against oppression and also in support of the Bahraini people.

Saudi Style of Execution

While the world was preparing to start the New Year, Saudi Arabia was preparing for a mass execution of dozens of people on a single day. On January 2nd 2016, Saudi Arabia’s Interior Ministry announced the execution of 47 prisoners on terrorism charges, including the Saudi Shiite cleric, Nimr Al-Nimr. According to Reuters, besides Al-Nimr, three of those executed were Shiite.

Saudi Ministry of Justice spokesman Mansour Al-Qufari said: “Four of the executions were implemented by firing squad, while the rest were beheaded by a sword.” Al-Qufari stressed: “Security forces will not hesitate at all to punish terrorists and instigators.”

The 47 Saudis were accused of sedition, disobedience and embracing the extremist (takfiri) approach, which contains doctrines outside of the main stream of Islam (Khawarej or rebels). They were accused of violating the holy book, the sanctity of Sunni consensus of the nation’s predecessors (Salaf) and participating and perpetrating murderous and terrorist acts against the Saudi military and security forces.

Saudi Arabia’s Grand Mufti Sheikh Abdulaziz Al-Sheikh defended the executions as in line with Islamic Sharia and described them as “just and merciful to the prisoners.”

James Lynch, Deputy Director of the Middle East and North Africa Program at Amnesty International said that Saudi Arabia’s executions in 2015 “coupled with the secretive and arbitrary nature of court decisions and executions in the kingdom, leave us no option but to take these latest warning signs very seriously…Among those who are at imminent risk of execution are these six Shi’a Muslim activists who were clearly convicted in unfair trials. It is clear that the Saudi Arabian authorities are using the guise of counter-terrorism to settle political scores,” Lynch added.

Long History of Execution

Saudi Arabia has a long history of executing people. According to an International Amnesty report 2014/15, “authorities in Bahrain, Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates (UAE) were unrelenting in their efforts to stifle dissent and stamp out any sign of opposition to those holding power, confident that their main allies among the western democracies were unlikely to demur.”

In recent years, Saudi authorities made an “extensive use of the death penalty” to execute dozens by public beheading. At least 151 people were put to death in 2015, the highest recorded figure since 1995. This is an average of 12 persons every month.

Historical Allies

While some voices were modest, others were explicit in condemning the Saudi executions. Indeed, the western response to Saudi Arabia’s public beheadings is delicate in comparison to ISIS’s public beheadings.

UN Secretary General Ban Ki Moon was dismayed by Saudi Arabia’s actions, whereas the US Secretary of State, John Kerry, said executing Al-Nimr risks “exacerbating sectarian tensions” between Iran and Saudi Arabia.

Germany’s Foreign Ministry described the death penalty as an inhumane punishment. “The cleric’s execution strengthens our existing concerns about the growing tensions and the deepening rifts in the region.”

The Saudis as well as western allies know that the brutality of the executions is going to be forgiven as was the Bahraini suppression during the Arab uprisings. Backed by other Gulf States, Bahrain brutally cracked down on protests by using ammunition in Shiite-majority villages. The reserved western reactions condemning the violence illustrated the nature of alliances among the West and the Gulf States. Joe Stork, the deputy Middle East director at Human Rights Watch, described the crackdown as follows: “Bahrain has brutally punished those protesting peacefully for greater freedom and accountability while the US and other allies looked the other way.”

In the light of international indifference, there is little hope that Saudi Arabia will respond to concerned voices, be they political, religious or social.

  • Rocking the G7: Trump Stomps His Allies

  • U.S. Cyber Policy, Beyond Ones and Zeros

  • The Situation in Nicaragua Deteriorates

  • The Spanish Labyrinth

  • Dark Precedents: Matteo Salvini, the MV Tampa and Refugees

  • American Rights: Guns, Drugs, and the Healing Power of Common Sense

  • Pushing Huawei Out: Australia, the Solomon Islands and the Internet

  • Meeting on the Island of Death From Behind: The Kim-Trump Summit

  • Elite Atrocities: Australia’s Special Forces in Afghanistan

  • China: Large Boost in Baby Numbers Unlikely?

  • Before the Next Storm: How to Strengthen Small Island States

  • Tanzania’s Worrying Democracy Deficit