Photo illustration by John Lyman

Politics

/

The Government Shutdown Is a Betrayal of the American People

At midnight on October 1, the federal government stumbled into another shutdown—a ritual of brinkmanship that long ago ceased to be theater and now borders on negligence. Congress failed to pass basic appropriations, and a partisan standoff hardened into a national crisis. This is not mere Washington dysfunction. It is a direct blow to the livelihoods, health, and ambitions of millions. Furloughed workers are staring at empty bank accounts. Families are recalculating rent, groceries, and childcare. The human cost is mounting by the hour, and it is time to name this for what it is: an abdication of duty by leaders more interested in scoring points than serving the public.

The origins are depressingly familiar. Republicans and Democrats, dug in over spending priorities and a grab bag of ideological riders, let the fiscal year expire without a lifeline. The Senate tried and failed—four times in as many days—to advance competing proposals. Then lawmakers decamped for the weekend, leaving the country to absorb the damage. Assigning blame will not restart the government. But it is worth saying plainly that the victims here are not the professional combatants on cable news. They are the people whose lives do not pause just because Congress did.

Begin with the federal workforce. Roughly three-quarters of a million so-called “non-essential” employees—about 40 percent of the government’s staff—have been furloughed without pay. These are not faceless bureaucrats; they are the people who make the country function. Air traffic controllers keep our skies safe. Scientists pursue medical breakthroughs. Park rangers protect public lands. Even active-duty service members and federal law-enforcement officers, who continue to report for duty, are confronting delayed paychecks. For families already navigating inflation and flat wages, a missed paycheck is not an abstraction; it is rent deferred, a college deposit imperiled, a grocery bill trimmed to the bone.

The ripple effects extend far beyond Washington. Social Security, a lifeline for more than 70 million retirees, disabled Americans, and survivors, faces processing delays that can leave vulnerable seniors waiting for checks. Air travel slows as TSA screeners and FAA staff are sidelined, snarling trips and commerce. National parks shut their gates, depriving communities of tourism dollars during peak seasons. Passport and visa processing drags, upending study-abroad plans and business trips. Each closure is its own small wound; together they amount to a nationwide injury.

Immigrants and asylum seekers, already navigating an overburdened system, face even longer waits. Non-detained immigration courts—the arena of due process for hundreds of thousands—are on indefinite pause, deepening backlogs that will take years to unwind. In health care, the scheduled expiration of expanded Medicare telehealth coverage collides disastrously with the shutdown, depriving rural patients of virtual visits when access is most crucial. Clinical trials that rely on federal approvals freeze in place. Across the research ecosystem, federally funded work—from climate modeling to cancer labs—stalls as agencies suspend grants and fellowships that fuel discovery.

The economic toll is immediate and compounding. Each day siphons billions from GDP, idles contractors, and spooks markets, with potential knock-on effects for Federal Reserve rate decisions and a labor market already flashing contradictory signals. Small businesses tethered to federal contracts teeter. Housing initiatives designed to address the affordability crisis stall, while underused federal buildings sit dark—assets that might be converted to homes for families who need them. We have seen this movie before. The 35-day shutdown of 2018–2019 did not merely bruise the economy in the moment; it eroded public trust and widened inequities that lingered well after the lights came back on.

This is not governance; it is governance by tantrum. The immediate fix is not complicated, only politically inconvenient: reconvene and pass a clean continuing resolution to fund the government at current levels through the end of the fiscal year. No riders. No poison pills. No parliamentary games. If necessary, the White House should broker the agreement and insist that shared priorities—disaster relief, veterans’ services, basic operations—take precedence over manufactured culture-war skirmishes. That is not capitulation; it is competence.

But triage is not reform. To end the cycle, Congress should adopt structural guardrails: automatic continuing resolutions to prevent future shutdowns; binding timelines for appropriations; and real incentives for cross-aisle bargaining rather than performative intransigence. Voters did not elect a circus. They elected representatives to do the routine work that makes ambitious work possible. It is past time for President Trump and his Cabinet to treat that obligation with the seriousness it deserves. Budgeting is not a televised brawl; it is stewardship.

Every delayed paycheck and closed door is a small demonstration of the government’s failure to meet its most basic obligations. Americans deserve better. Demand better. Call your senators. Flood the Capitol switchboard. Remember this episode at the ballot box. The United States is greater than its gridlock—if we choose to be. End the shutdown now.