Photo illustration by John Lyman

World News

/

Britain Is Finally Coming to Terms With Brexit’s Failure

When British Prime Minister Andy Burnham meets European Union leaders in Brussels on Friday, November 20, both sides will arrive knowing what they want, what they can offer, and what concessions they expect in return. After years of political hostility and economic disruption, Britain and the EU have an opportunity to begin repairing a relationship badly damaged by Brexit.

Many EU governments would welcome Britain back into the European fold. They have lost valuable exports to the British market, while their citizens have lost opportunities to work and build lives in the UK. Portuguese nurses, for example, once prized by National Health Service managers for their university education and professional skills, could spend several years working in Britain, improving their English, and contributing to the local economy.

The economic consequences of Brexit have become increasingly difficult to dismiss. Universities and economic research institutes have produced a steady stream of evidence documenting the damage to British trade, investment, and productivity. Financial services have proved more resilient, with Britain emerging as a major European center for cryptocurrency trading. Yet the financial interests surrounding that industry, including wealthy investors and offshore operators, have also helped sustain elements of Britain’s anti-European political establishment.

Still, the EU’s 27 member states have little intention of granting Britain special privileges. Burnham understands that reality and has made clear that he is not seeking an immediate return to EU membership.

Nor does he appear eager to risk another referendum on rejoining, which could once again hand enormous influence to an overwhelmingly hostile press and the political interests that helped finance the 2016 Leave campaign.

The economic difficulties are not confined to Britain. Some EU member states have enjoyed considerably stronger growth, but France, like the UK, faces serious public debt pressures as governments struggle to reconcile spending demands with mounting borrowing costs.

There is nevertheless considerable scope for agreement. Burnham and his European counterparts should be able to make progress on aligning British food safety and agricultural standards with those of the EU. British food and drink exports to the bloc have fallen by more than a third since 2019, illustrating the lasting consequences of Brexit and the deeply flawed trade arrangements negotiated under Boris Johnson.

Predictably, opponents of closer European cooperation are mobilizing. A group calling itself “Stay Out” has entered the debate, while Conservative shadow ministers continue their attacks on Burnham. Opposition parties are expected to oppose governments, but the daily denunciations from Kemi Badenoch and her colleagues increasingly resemble political background noise rather than a serious alternative.

Conservatives hoping to return to government in two years will eventually have to decide whether defending Johnson’s Brexit legacy, or following Nigel Farage’s political agenda, offers any credible route back to power.

For Britain and the EU, the immediate challenge is more practical: repairing the mutually damaging features of an agreement that has imposed unnecessary economic costs on both sides. British voters have become increasingly skeptical of Brexit’s supposed benefits, and the political argument for rebuilding ties with Europe is growing stronger.

Insisting that Brexit has been an unqualified success increasingly resembles the economic orthodoxy of the 1920s, when defenders of Britain’s return to the gold standard argued that monetary rigidity was essential to the country’s international standing, even as the policy undermined economic recovery.

John Maynard Keynes challenged that orthodoxy, recognizing the damage caused by policies defended more through ideological conviction than economic evidence. A famous remark often attributed to him captures the importance of intellectual flexibility: “When the facts change, I change my mind. What do you do, sir?”

The facts surrounding Brexit have changed, and the economic case for trade isolationism has steadily weakened. There will be no dramatic ceremony welcoming Britain back into the EU, nor should anyone expect an overnight reversal of the 2016 referendum.

What is emerging instead is a more pragmatic British approach to Europe, one that gradually abandons the ideological Europhobia that produced Brexit in favor of a relationship grounded in economic realities and national interests. The task now is to ensure that Britain’s future relationship with its closest neighbors strengthens rather than undermines the country’s prosperity.