The Platform

Apple Books

Henryk M. Broder and Reinhard Mohr’s Durchs irre Germanistan provides a provocative analysis of contemporary Germany.

Durchs irre Germanistan: Notizen aus der Ampel-Republik by Henryk M. Broder and Reinhard Mohr provides a provocative analysis of contemporary Germany, a nation grappling with its identity amid ideals of moral superiority and the stark realities of political and economic challenges. The authors craft a narrative that is at once humorous and grave, dissecting the complexities of a society striving for global leadership while wrestling with internal contradictions.

The book examines the paradox of German morality, a concept that, according to Broder and Mohr, often translates into a sense of superiority over others. This moral stance, they argue, has led to a series of domestic failures across defense, economics, and innovation. Despite these shortcomings, Germany persists in positioning itself as a global exemplar, a stance underscored by the nation’s critical view of policies in other countries, notably the United States, particularly during electoral processes.

Broder and Mohr are especially critical of the current “traffic light” coalition government, highlighting its failure to address pressing issues such as the war in Ukraine, inflation, and economic downturn. They point out the government’s seemingly dissonant messaging, promising stability and improvement through measures like cannabis legalization and flexible gender identity choices, while substantial policy contradictions and failures lurk beneath the surface.

One striking example of this dissonance is the stance on nuclear power. The authors recount how Economics Minister Robert Habeck acknowledged the importance of nuclear energy during a visit to Ukraine, only to later reaffirm Germany’s commitment to phasing out nuclear power, a decision that symbolizes broader policy inconsistencies and ideological platitudes that fail to address Germany’s pressing needs.

Broder and Mohr’s critique extends beyond the current government, contrasting it with what they describe as the “golden era” of Angela Merkel’s pragmatic governance. Yet, they also note the continuity of challenges from Merkel’s tenure to the present, including military underfunding, the nuclear phase-out, and refugee policy decisions, underscoring the deep-rooted nature of these issues.

Durchs irre Germanistan challenges readers to reflect on the complex interplay between moral aspirations and political realities in Germany. Broder and Mohr offer a critical yet insightful perspective on the nation’s struggle to reconcile its self-image with the pragmatic demands of governance and international relations.

Eva Kneifel is studying Politics and History at FernUniversität Campus Hagen.